“`html
My Customers Won’t Have a Plumber Anymore. They’ll Have an Agent That Shops Plumbers.
I’ve been watching this shift happen in real time and it’s brutal. For twenty years my restoration contractors have built their businesses on being “my guy.” The insurance adjuster who always called them first. The property manager who never got three bids because they trusted them. That world is dying faster than anyone wants to admit.
The “My Guy” Economy Is Over
Here’s what’s actually happening. Customers aren’t going to have a restoration company anymore. They’re going to have an agent that shops restoration companies every single time. Same with plumbers. Same with electricians. Same with every trade that thinks loyalty is still a business model.
The agent won’t have a favorite. It won’t care about the Christmas cards or the beers at the end of a tough job. It will have perfect information about every job you’ve ever done, every review you’ve ever received, every price you’ve ever quoted, every insurance carrier you work with, and every complaint that’s ever been filed. Then it will make the cold, rational decision about who gets the work this time.
That’s what agentic commerce actually looks like in the trades. Not some sci-fi fantasy. Just brutal efficiency replacing human relationships.
What This Actually Costs Us
Everyone’s talking about the efficiency gains. Nobody’s talking about the human cost.
My restoration guys built their businesses by being there at 2am when the pipe burst. By taking the jobs that weren’t profitable because the customer was in a jam. By developing the kind of judgment that only comes from doing the same work for fifteen years in the same town. That kind of skin in the game doesn’t compute in an agent’s algorithm.
The agent will optimize for the current job, not the relationship. It will see the one bad review from 2019 and weigh it against the 87 perfect ones. It will notice that your price is three percent higher than the new kid who just got his license and has no idea what he’s doing. It won’t care that you know the difference between a job that needs to be done right and one that just needs to be done cheap.
This is the part that keeps me up at night. We’re replacing human judgment with machine judgment in industries where being wrong costs people their homes, their businesses, or their life savings. And we’re pretending this is just progress.
The New Game
The contractors who survive won’t be the best at relationships anymore. They’ll be the best at feeding perfect data to these agents. Every job documented. Every metric tracked. Every outcome measured. The guys who used to win by being trustworthy are going to lose to the guys who win by being legible to machines.
Some of them will adapt. Most won’t. The ones who’ve built their entire identity around being the guy everyone calls first are in for a rude awakening. That identity is becoming worthless.
The universal commerce protocol everyone’s building isn’t just connecting buyers and sellers. It’s fundamentally changing what it means to be good at a trade. The best plumber in town might not get the work if his data profile doesn’t look right to the agent.
I’ve spent years helping these companies tell their stories and build their systems. Now I’m watching the ground shift under their feet. The customers they’ve served for decades won’t be choosing them anymore. An agent will be choosing for them, job by job, with zero loyalty and perfect memory.
This is what agentic commerce actually means for the service economy. Not cooler apps. Not faster transactions. The end of “my guy” and the rise of “the agent that shops my guys.”
Will’s Take: The trades are about to learn what newspapers learned fifteen years ago. Being essential to your customers isn’t enough when something else becomes better at deciding for them. The agent doesn’t need your coffee chats or your reputation or your handshake. It just needs your data. And it’s coming for all of us.
“`
Leave a Reply